Aloha!
Honestly, I think that they are all worth consideration and worth wearing.
My favorite is the Classic, but I also like "Special Reserve". It's not for everyone, but I really like it. Then there's "Eau de Cologne Lime Sec" and "Citrus Musk". And finally, my Grandfather's fave, "Bay Rum". I like anything Lime or Citrus so the Lime Sec and Citrus Musk agree with me. But all of Clubman's aftershaves are so economical, it's amazing. What's the average price for these? $10 delivered or $7 at your local supply store? I have all of them in my "Fragrance" cabinet. They are probably all available from Amazon or your favorite Barber supply company. So pick one or two if you don't already have them on hand and have a ball.
Whatever you do, enjoy the journey my friend. Enjoy the journey. Or as the Hawaiians say, "Nanea i ka hele ana"
Mahalo!
-ZipZop