I also need a new deodorant

While reading MickyLee's thread about deodorants I was wondering about quality deodorants. I have extremely sensitive skin because of which many deodorants cause a rash. I currently have tried many commercially available deodorants and have found only a limited few offer a functional item for me. Lately I have successfully been using degree solid. I have been wanting a deodorant with a scent that avoids the teenybopper standard. I have tried tom's of maine and it rashed me up with the first use. I know having read mickylees thread that many of the companies we deal with offer an adult scented alternative. My question is which of these products will work and will not irritate my skin? Also are there any boutique guys who offer a deodorant.

-G

Ever try the Dry Idea roll-on? I've had the same thing- rashes from other stuff, but this has been working great for years now. Not too much scent option, but hey...

Arm & Hammer does a great job and works for 24 hours if need be.

Silver2

Are you talking deodorant or antiperspirants?
I never use antiperspirants, but the most effective deodorant I've ever come across is Witch Hazel. Go figure.

My biggest problem is the scents that are available, but when I looked into alternate brands they caused problems. I get very tired of these "scents" and want something more traditional.
The arm & hammer caused a rash.
I use both deodorants and antiperspirants (not at the same time). I will have to try witch hazel, what are the applications? What is the longevity?
I was looking to go with a deodorant since they tend to be less harsh on the skin and I no longer am working a job where I sweat from 6 am to 5 pm.

-G

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wdwrx

Are you talking deodorant or antiperspirants?
I never use antiperspirants, but the most effective deodorant I've ever come across is Witch Hazel. Go figure.

---

Witch Hazel? Really? I'll have to try that, tomorrow.

At alot of health food stores you can obtain a natural crystal that you wet under water and use for deodorant. I have not seen one that has a scent but i cannot use any other deodorant because it makes me rash. I have been using this for atleast 5 years and have never had a problem.

I have to wear deodorant, because if I can't sweat I'll overheat, but I have a hard time finding anything that keeps the smell under control. I've come to the conclusion that there might be substances in the deodorant that actually feed the bacteria and make the situation worse.
After my last brand was discontinued, out of desperation, I thought I'd try Witch Hazel, just splashed under the ol' pits, and I was amazed at the level of odor control. It far exceeds anything I've ever tried, including anti-bacterial body soap (Cetaphil) which worked pretty well.

If used with regular deodorant on top, the scent of the deodorant will actually last for the day. But, of course, YMMV.:)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prosneek

At alot of health food stores you can obtain a natural crystal that you wet under water and use for deodorant. I have not seen one that has a scent but i cannot use any other deodorant because it makes me rash. I have been using this for atleast 5 years and have never had a problem.

---

Thai Crystal is a common brand of it. If you have Whole Foods Market close by, they probably have it. Also cheap and easy at Amazon.

ps Whole Foods also has essential oils (at least by me) like bay rum, clove, orange, etc
-sorry that was little off topic, the oils arent to mixed with the crystal stick, but good for other needs

I use an alum block and/or Nivea which is an anti-perspirant. That may be useless information for you but just in case you've never tried it I'd recommend giving it a go.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by deighaingeal

I have tried tom's of maine and it rashed me up with the first use.

-G

---

I was going to recommend Tom's of maine :(

i don't have problems with rashes or irritation.. but i try to be as natural as possible.. for years i used burt's bees herbal deodorant spray.. it's basically alcohol, lemon oil, sage oil, and lavender oil.. it works great and keeps things simple.

here's a link..
Herbal Deodorant - Burt's Bees

also... although this product works great.. i finally decided to stop using deodorant all together.. i now shave my arm pits and just to natural.. the lack of hair cuts down on sweat and odor. on occasion i've splashed a little bayrum under there when needing to freshen up.. which is only when i've been very active and need to go someplace where i might be noticed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by deighaingeal

While reading MickyLee's thread about deodorants I was wondering about quality deodorants. I have extremely sensitive skin because of which many deodorants cause a rash. I currently have tried many commercially available deodorants and have found only a limited few offer a functional item for me. Lately I have successfully been using degree solid. I have been wanting a deodorant with a scent that avoids the teenybopper standard. I have tried tom's of maine and it rashed me up with the first use. I know having read mickylees thread that many of the companies we deal with offer an adult scented alternative. My question is which of these products will work and will not irritate my skin? Also are there any boutique guys who offer a deodorant.

-G

---

Have you tried Tom's of Maine deodorant? I got it at drugstore.com.

Well I tried the witch hazel today and after trimming three trees since early this morning I smell like nothing more than willow and walnut. Thanks for all of the advice I'm going to try the nivea tomorrow I don't have alum like I should, but I'll have to get some eventually so I'll try then.
BTW with the witch hazel I could use my Alraz SoCa cologne!

-G

Have you tried Mennen Speed Stick Original Deodorant? It's very traditional in scent and it smells an awful lot like the old Yardley Shaving soap of yore - very fougere and very masculine. I've used it off and on over the years and recently settled back in with it. Glad I did.

Regards,
EL

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by elbonator

Have you tried Mennen Speed Stick Original Deodorant? It's very traditional in scent and it smells an awful lot like the old Yardley Shaving soap of yore - very fougere and very masculine. I've used it off and on over the years and recently settled back in with it. Glad I did.

Regards,
EL

---

I have not, but I will look into it as funds form. Thank you all.

-G

deighaingeal,

I bought what is called a "Thai Deodorant stone" and have been using it for a couple of months. It works ridiculously good! I have no odor in my armpits for 24 hours, even after grappling for 2 hours. I have been using a deodorant called: Nature's Gate Summer Spice Deodorant Stick. It smells very good! Has some ingredients like witch hazel, sage myrrh, and some fragrance oils. I really like Nature's Gate products, I also use their toothpastes. I prefer them over Tom's of Maine. I think I will try Ogallala Bay Rum deodorant next. Thanks Dirtychrome for the link!

Have you tried deodorant powder ? I have a terribly bad funky armpit odour, like cockroach smell, so I need a deodorant. however not just any deodorants, because I don't want it to clog up my skin or give me bad smell afterwards. I've been using SPAM SPAM SPAM deodorant for many years now and I have no more armpit odours. Even when I sweat I don't have any odours, this deodorant works great and I'm loving it. I can't go out in the day without putting it on. Even when I sweat my armpits don't have any smell. I applied 1 pinch and it's all to it for the whole day without worries about any smell afterwards. There's no after sport smell or odour masking. I would recommend it to anyone who has underarm odour.

I can't use deodorant or antiperspirant, get all itchy and red. Tried it on/off since a young teen and just can't do it. The only thing that works for me is alum block (I use a razorock stick) and some talc like clubman. It keeps me dry and no sweaty smell... although I am one of the lucky ones that don't get pit odor, so I don't know if that would work for those who do.

The issue is arm smell is a human defense mechanism and is caused by bacterial growing in that area. Most deodorants out there aim to paint the skin with a substance that makes the area inhospitable to the bacteria so hence no smell. The problem with many of the herbal products is if you really sweat alot the product simply washes away from the sweat. Most commercial preps use the same aluminum compound along with another chemical to reduce sweating. If you want the ultimate in sweat and odor control contact an outfit called Kleinerts. They specialize in sweat control clothes. They sell an unscented pad you wipe on your underarm area and it really works. I sweat like a pig and it's the only product that actually works for me and I've tried them all at one time or another.

For all those talking about Thai crystal and such - it is just good old alum, which we all may have laying around anyways. There would be no cost to try it if you already have it.

From wikipedia: "Alum's antibacterial properties contribute to its traditional use as an underarm deodorant. It has been used for this purpose in Europe; Mexico; Thailand, where it is called Sarn-Som; throughout Asia; and in the Philippines, where it is called Tawas. Today, potassium alum is sold commercially for this purpose as a "deodorant crystal," often in a protective plastic case."
wikipedia, under Cosmetic

Personally, I make my own stick deo and so can add any fragrance I prefer.

I have been using Grace Cosmetics roll-on deodourant for years now and have never had a problem, even when on exercise with the military.
It's all aloe vera based and natural. If you can find a distributor in your area, try it and see if it helps and, if it doesn't, there's a money back guarantee.

I have been using a crystal (alum salt) for the last 10 years. It does a great job; an added bonus, and the reason that I went to crystals, it eliminates the yellow gunk that accumulates on your t-shirt. Yes, if you use a deodorant stick, the underarm area of your t-shirt turns nasty.

One trick with the crystal stick that I use: when you rinse your face after shaving, just rub some water in your armpits where you want the deodorant to go. Then rub the crystal stick on your armpits. It glides much easier than trying to wet the crystal stick and then applying.