I personally don't have the knowledge on the subject of Filarmonica to determine if either party is off on their facts.
But,,,,
Richmondesi,, Robin stepped into the thread
http://straightrazorpalace.com/brush...h-100-a-3.html
in a manner that puts his interpersonal skills at question & there are still members waiting for him to substantiate some of the claims in that thread. I've never met Robin or worked with him on SRP, but I did give him the benefit of the doubt on the brush thread linked above & visited his "Homepage" that he has linked under his SRP name. After reading for quite a while, I stick with my above assessment of him.
Robin's work on SRP has not gone unnoticed by members here, who are trying to follow in his footsteps to maintain the quality of this site. SRP has maintained it's status at the top, AFAIC, because of it's foundation being based on facts & the administration's resolve to keep it that way, by holding it's members accountable for their words.