Search:

Yes, I have both. I tend to prefer the original, but there is something alluring about the lime. The lime seems to have a more medicinal fragrance (at least to me it does) but I still like it.
...

Oh, and I thought I'd ask while we're on the subject, something about Pinaud's bay rum.

I have a general fondness for all Pinaud aftershaves (yeah, even Lilac Vegetal). The appeal is partly due...

I think the second group is most appropriate. Can't remember all the ingredients (they were listed on the box, now long gone) but it is certainly a high end bay rum.

Scott

I'm also a bay rum addict..er..fan going back about 20 years or so.

Didn't see Caswell-Massey Michelson's Bay Rum in your grouping. It is one of my alltime favorite bay rums. Very warm, rich and...