Search:

Unfortunately, Classic Shaving is currently out-of-stock on Captain's Bay Rum.

Try this site: Caribbean Bay Rum Captain Smith's Island Spice All Purpose Lotion.

Try Straight Razor Designs. I believe that they at least have the Pinaud Bay Rum.

Barclay Crocker has the Royall Bay Rum and several other brands too.

I don't know where you can find Captain...