Search:

Not really a list .. but many of the names in this thread are actually links to where they are at ..

To be honest however if you want the best deals just Google the names and many sites will pop...

@Trimmy72 / Chris

Love the looks of the "Hold Fast" Bay Rum might have to try that out Thanks for feeding my addiction hehehe

Slur,
If the Ogallala turned your nose and you still want to try a Bay Rum, you will want to try one with the "Island Version" of the scent..

They tend to be a Lighter scent with very little too...

Thanks

John still has his Ebay store running Enjoy :)

Bay Rum, Cologne items in Ogallala Bay Rum store on eBay!


Also just so you know I am not happy with you :) in searching for his...

This is a Category 3 Bay Rum, made with Grain Alcohol, and Rum, along with scents Witch Hazel, and Glycerin..

82377

It is available here

Captain's Choice Bay Rum Aftershave

Not bad at...

The three "Standards" IMHO are Royall, Dominica, and Cap't Smiths

Mine came in the mail the other day from SRD..

This is a nice Island Scented Bay Rum no heavy Cloves..
I put this is Group 2

Very Refreshing and the scent stays "lightly" there all day....

Hmmmm good question...

I know many of these say they have serious lineage if you read the labels :)

For me the Gold Standard is Royall Bay Rhum...

I can remember buying this for Pops...

Bay Rum Addiction... it is a terrible monkey to carry on yer back... :)

These are straight ole time Barber shop ones just pure Alcohol, Water and Fragrance...

Left to right as you can see

Black Magic bay rum

Constanza bay rum that looks to be imported but I...

Many places will carry some type of Bay Rum, check more Drugstores rather than large box places...

Online every vendor on here carries some, but we do have one Canadian contributing vendor and I...

These are three more for Group Two we have Alcohol and Real Bay oil, two are Mentholated...

From Left to right

McLas Mentholated Bay Rum

Benjamin's Mentholated Bay Rum

Benjamin's Bay...

I moved this thread out of the old reviews section since it really doesn't fit in the new review format, it is pretty much just a Bay Rum thread

I just ordered 8 new ones to add as soon as they...

One of the door prizes I ended up with at the NC meet-up was the Ogallala Bay Rum Sandalwood....
Now keep in mind that scent is a personal thing, but this stuff smells great to me and I gotta say...

Yeah that Capt's really lights ya up in the morning :eek:
As to wheel guns quite a few actually, but to what yer talking about I have a Ruger Vaquero .45 LC 5 1/2 in barrel..... I just need to...

This one made by Pussers Rum, is a for sure group three, Bay Rum,made with double distilled alcohol (rum)
Long lasting scent and feels good on the skin... This one is also a little pricey for a bay...

Thanks for the post Paulo I love seeing different kinds of Bay Rum, and I sure the other guys do too...

Doc:
I searched on Amazon but watch how they advertise it, my personal fav is th all...

Yep and it just went on the list of gotta try LOL
Thanks for posting Rusty
Reading the link it looks as thought it might actually go in group 3, the sugar cane reference, could mean a real rum base...

Scott:
Would you put this in the second group then ?????? it sounds like it may have some type of conditioners in there
Thanks for the info

I would recommend the Capt Smith's Caribbean regardless of price at this point, but it should be less than $20 shipped....I would only recommend this because I think it gives a good all around Bay...

I decided to bring this thread back to life finally "After the Crash":
This is the Bay Rum Parade!!!! :nj


I will break this down into three groups, The basic Alcohol and scent, The ones with...