Search:

Just to be clear I don't note a Difference between the Smith's and Honing oil

I tried my Charnley with water and lather and never got a great edge, not bad but never Wow !!!

I switched to oil...

Smith's Honing Solution... See if you can find it on your side of the pond... It runs about $5 a bottle and is great for people like me that hate the mess of using real oil on my oil stones ...
...