Printable View
Hi--I couldn't find an answer to this, and (admittedly) it is subjective anyway, but...in looking at razors, I see ratings such as fair, good, great, and excellent. Are there published criteria for how to judge the condition? Poor, fair, and good are pretty obvious, but is great better than excellent, or vice versa?
Thanks,
Stuart
I'd just ask for better pictures :gl:
every seller puts the grading they're comfortable with, so the variations are huge.
i do them in the order of the drop down menu
excellent > great > good > fair > poor
for example, i don't call it great or excellent if the blade is pitted, but that doesn't seem to be the norm.
in any case i take pictures with proper exposure so that the condition is clear, and that's the most important part.
you can always ask the seller for more pictures and clarification.
That helps a lot--since I haven't sold anything yet, I haven't seen the drop-down menu.Quote:
Originally Posted by gugi
Putting together a set of guidelines might be a good idea--it would provide some guidance so the ads would have some consistency.
Thanks!
It seems that someone did try to standardize those terms at one time, but it never caught on.
It would be difficult to eliminate any subjectivity there.
I always try to get pictures that show all the flaws, and describe in detail anything that is "wrong" with the razor.
Agreed.Quote:
Originally Posted by HNSB
I have found the ads here to be very good in that regard...for the most part, people seem to go above and beyond in describing flaws.Quote:
I always try to get pictures that show all the flaws, and describe in detail anything that is "wrong" with the razor.
There's this in the wiki.Quote:
Originally Posted by greyhawk
Thanks, that is exactly what I was looking for but didn't find.Quote:
Originally Posted by AlanII
However, I see that absolutely no one follows it! :)
Well, that's likely because the terms used in the Wiki don't match with the drop down list, so they would be impossible to follow.
I think you will find that most of the sellers will appraise a item they are selling equal to or actually downgrade the rating on the item. No true gentleman will sell you something that it is NOT.
Just please dont post something like "Near-NOS!!!" or "rescaled, honed, and restored from NOS"
This isnt ebay.....
Ha, I couldn't agree more. I recently saw one that said "Brand new, I've only shaved with it three times..."Quote:
Originally Posted by Slartibartfast
Well, dude, then it ain't brand new any more...
Anyway, I'm in the buying stage, not selling--I'm trying to sort through everyone's descriptions and different quality photos. I must say everyone seems very conservative in their ratings, so no worries.
Thanks to everyone who responded.
Stuart
I just noticed a thread titled "almost NOS" - I think it might be a razor in the making, I am about to go check it outQuote:
Originally Posted by Slartibartfast
Maybe we should institute a standard similar to NRA guidelines where either it is NIB or rated at a percentage of NIB, such as 95% perfect or 90% and so forth. Just an idea.