My take on the Clubman cream is that it's probably not bad to keep around for when you're in a hurry. Just wipe it on and go to town shaving. Beats the can goo.
It doesn't give a bad shave, but not the best. It does have some cushion to it, but it goes on thin. The scent isn't anywhere near Orginal Clubman.
But, today was an ultimate Clubman day for me, shampoo, shave cream and then the aftershave.