I won't give a name, but we have a fine member here that DOES like the rose scented MDC. He told me about it a week ago. The scent is a personal thing. Now, it's not me. As most of you know, my sniffer dont work so well any more. I love MDC for its abilities. This is what I look for in a soap. All soaps. Scent means next to nothing to me. Its too bad the Rose Scent didn't get a better review. But you all know better than me when it comes to scent.