This is my opinion only you might agree or disagree.

I decided to give stirlings full line up a try, I used the bath soap, shampoo bar, shaving soap and after shaves. I do not use pre shave oil so I did not try it.

The bath soap snd shampoo bar are great work well and smell nice.

The shaving soap, I know obie places it in tier 2. I think the lather quality is on par with tier 1 but it is a little harder to get the right lather.

I do 3 stage after shave, witch hazel, alcohol based and then balm. All three from stirling are great my only complaint is the balm is thick making it hard not to get two much from the container.

The best part is this company gets it all the products are in the same scent so no scent clothing at all.