There are many a good product that have been offered up here already. At this point the only way to know if any are right for you is to try them. I suggest you try some from the entire spectrum to see if you distinguish any vagaries and develop any preferences from them.
My personal recommendation is to try the AOS soap. It is, IMHO, one of the finest shaving soaps available. But only by trying it will you discover if you agree. Hope that helps.
Regards,
EL