I picked up some SCS cream (New Spice) a few weeks back. The scent is great, but for the life of me I cannot get it to lather properly. It seems that the slightest bit too much water, and it turns into a runny mess. I drain all the water from my bowl and flick all the excess water from my brush, still a thin lather.

I also received a sample of one of their soaps, and have no such problems.

Ideas?