I have accumulated quite a bunch of soaps since I begun shaving with straights: Proraso green, MWF, Tabac, Williams, DRH Arlington on its way. On the other hand, I'm only on samples regarding creams, so I think I'll opt for a cream.
Maybe it won't be Trumper's, though, since I have yet to try all the samples I received from T&H, and then the Edwin Jagger I should receive with my DRH package. I also want to try Castle Forbes, but maybe I'll get the Limes one without sampling it (even if I know I shouldn't). There's a lot of competition taking place.
Any additional input is always welcome.