Tried Mitchell's Wool Fat today
Just started straight razor shaving a few months back and started with the cheap Van Hagen soap that Walmart sells and wanted to try something better so I ordered some Mitchell's Wool Fat and I like it!
Smoother shave and my face is soft as a baby's butt when I am done. I like it! ;)
I also bought some C.O. Bigelow's shaving cream in the tube at a Bath and Body Works in Jacksonville, NC on our trip and like it as well.
It's made by Proraso for them and is probably the best shaving cream I can get in normal stores here in my area.