I am sure this is a well worn topic but what the heck!!! I own both sizes, I have two 3" strops one is an English Bridal and the other is black latigo, both took some time to soften but now they are in great shape. My other stop is some "made in China special" I think it says "Franks shaving... Maybe it just the mechanics of my hand, or using an X pattern I but I get a far nicer edge on the 2.5" I doubt highly it has anything to do with top quality Chinese leather... So what are your thoughts??