Hi guys. I don't post much but have been reading a ton. Thanks to everyone right off the top.

I have been shaving with a Wade & Butcher Spanish/Irish point (I think that's what it's called; a bit oblique and rounded toe). I love the thick, heavy blade. It's got some geometry issues that I'll post in another folder.

Anyway, I was using a vintage Illinois strop (not sure which one, as the writing is worn). It seemed to be leaving scratches on the blade that weren't present post-honing (Norton 4/8), but I couldn't feel any bits of grit. A local shop suggested I clean it with my shaving soap and brush. I did, and it stripped the oil completely from the surface and left the strop a bit rougher. It was basically glazed before, which was either great (smooth) or less effective than ideal, I couldn't tell which.

Following the cleaning, I have oiled it heavily with neetsfoot oil several times so it is not dry. I have used the back of the blade to try to settle the surface back to normal, but it's clearly less 'glazed'. I think the scratching is reduced, but it's only been a few days and one honing.

Can anyone tell me whether cleaning a vintage strop like this should ever be done? I won't repeat anytime soon, and am assuming that leather likes to be used so it will be ok in the long run, but like you all, I am looking for a clean, sharp edge that is good to my face and doesn't get wrecked by my abuse.