First Restore - I'm not done yet!

Attachment 95509

Attachment 95510

This is my first attempt at a restore and I have learned much - but have a lot to learn. I suppose it's a good idea to see how an auction blade hones before going to all the trouble to restore and make scales.

I really wanted to try my hand at scales and had fun, so no regrets, but my last step was to (try to) hone this beast. I used 3 layers of tape and went through the progression thinking I had a good edge. My first shave this morning resulted in a really nice shave - except for the tip of the blade. The last 1/2" of the blade is not sharp.

I noticed that the nose does not make full contact on one side, but thought I had this corrected using a rolling x stroke. Apparently not - or maybe not yet. I'm not opposed to sending it out, but would like to learn, or at least know how to handle this situation.

Looks great.
I just did my first as well and as I have not learned honing "yet" I have no idea if it will hone properly but I will soon find out. For me it was still worth the learning experience ether way it turns out. Though I did not have to make any scales for mine. I had fun and learned a lot as I'm sure you did as well.

What a lovely job!!!
You certainly jumped in at the deep end for your first - and swam well, by the looks.
It is a beautiful blade too.
I wish it were mine - well done

I suppose if I want answers, I need to ask questions, which I did a very poor job of. Let me start over without starting a new thread:

I posted this thread some time back concerning the above blade:
http://straightrazorpalace.com/works...ht=#post950453

I thought there was the slightest amount of frown in the blade, so I slightly reshaped the middle to toe on a Tormek wet wheel. I held the blade at a 45 degree angle to the wheel and removed the frown. My instinct is that this did not effect the spine, so I don't know that this procedure would result in not being able to hone the toe, but I throw that out, for what it's worth.

My first attempt at setting the bevel was done with 2 layers of 3M. I noticed some light scratches on the blade above the bevel on the toe, so thinking I needed a little steeper angle, I went to 3 layers and completed the bevel ( I thought).

What I am asking is whether I should:

1. re-work the entire blade, starting with 1000K bevel set?
2. go back to work just the toe area in question? Add more tape?
3. send it out to one of the pros and miss the satisfaction and gratification of competing the project?
4. melt the sucker down and make a bracelet?
5. other?

Thanks for your collective help.

If the bevel is set correctly it should shave arm hair easilly along" the entire edge of the blade", if that the case or not i would use a marker on the edge and find a stroke that covers the entire edge. But dont let me see a thread called Wade and Butcher bracelet.

That wedge with those scales just pulls everything together. Is it a lead wedge? Those little subtle details just makes a razor look alot better "Thats my OCD talking". Very nice! That is my opinion though.

If someone had given me a razor that had been worked freehand on a grinder as you've just done, I'd go back to setting a bevel and I'd stay on the 1K stone with a magic marker test until it shaved arm hair all along the blade, before moving to a higher grit -- no matter how long it took.

I'd also suggest to this hypothetical fellow that he save his high end grinder for hatchets and wood chisels, smile.
Namaste,
Morty -_-

PS: awesome job on the scales!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JSmith1983

That wedge with those scales just pulls everything together. Is it a lead wedge? Those little subtle details just makes a razor look alot better "Thats my OCD talking". Very nice! That is my opinion though.

---

The wedge is brass. The original wedge appeared to be lead, but I preferred the brass.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Morty

If someone had given me a razor that had been worked freehand on a grinder as you've just done, I'd go back to setting a bevel and I'd stay on the 1K stone with a magic marker test until it shaved arm hair all along the blade, before moving to a higher grit -- no matter how long it took.

I'd also suggest to this hypothetical fellow that he save his high end grinder for hatchets and wood chisels, smile.
Namaste,
Morty -_-

PS: awesome job on the scales!

---

Sometimes I am a bit of a luddite, but i really don't think my shaping is the culprit, as it appears the spine may be worn a little differently on one side. That's one of the surprises that comes with buying from a photo, I guess. However, your advice about the grinder is taken to heart and will no longer be a razor restoration tool!

Magic marker it is!

Very nice! I like the brass wedge with the brass pins. I think it goes nice with the scales.

I have to say, I love the learning curve of this hobby.

Hay bro I'm just like you I wanted to do it or learn it all myself. I have two straights the second one i got needed only cleaning up (little rust) the first needed new scales so thats the what I did, made scales for it, birds eye mapel with clear acrelic wedge. Then the BIG! self let down I dont know honing from hoeing so I sent THEM both out to Lynn for ME that was the way to go "for now tell I get stones and learn how" but I think i know how you fell about it, you should keep at it tell you get it. And if the blade dies an honorable death in the persuite of the art then put it a picture frame and remember it fondly, then go to the fle market and get another or do that first for a practice blade. Anyway you go I dont think you will be happy tell you get it, really get it. :rock:
Rich

I guess if I'm going to admit that I took this beautiful blade to a grinder, I should go all out and admit the rest of my folly. As you can guess, I ain't split no atoms lately...

Tip: If you want to get a sharp edge all the way out to the toe, you have to hone all the way out to the toe! When I got out my gear to reset the bevel on this, I started with the marker, and lo and behold - I had not honed the toe. I guess I was in such a hurry to try this baby out, that I forgot the fundamentals.

After doing the job the right way, I shaved with the project and had an exceptional shave. Not only close, but amazingly smooth. This one goes into regular rotation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DBurnette

After doing the job the right way, I shaved with the project and had an exceptional shave. Not only close, but amazingly smooth. This one goes into regular rotation.

---

Life isn't about what happened to us in the past, nor is it about what we've done. Life is all about what we do next. Congratulations on a successful project!
Namaste,
Morty -_-

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Morty

Life isn't about what happened to us in the past, nor is it about what we've done. Life is all about what we do next. Congratulations on a successful project!
Namaste,
Morty -_-

---

That's very kind. i actually had a ball doing the restoration, even learning from the error, um, oversight. I don't really regret the grinding part, as the frown is gone and i didn't remove even a millimeter. I have 2 more W & Bs to restore and am greatly looking forward to getting them started. I wish I had taken before pictures, but all of them have been on the buffer already.

That is one beautiful razor. If it shaves as nice as it looks you have a winner.