This is a long shot since it sounds like a classic case of straight up razor burn. And if that is the case, the advice already given is my only contribution. But the long shot is that perhaps the soaps/creams you are using contain something that is irritating your skin or aggravating an allergy. I find that many of the highly scented creams (Truefitt and Hill, Taylor, AOS) to leave my face on fire after a shave. Its more of a chemical burn than a razor burn. Its not likely to be your problem but it may be worth considering if what you are using is all or mostly the same. And its possible that its a pre or post shave item as well.