First I would find someone to look at the blade, while it is gone break out the fusion and learn how the brush and lather work together to get good lather. Also get some practice with dull razor shaped objects on the strop to get some muscle memory. Watch more videos.

There are probably a few people in your area, here's a members link that lists Indiana as their location http://straightrazorpalace.com/membe...sername&order= Senior members and ones listed as mentors will for sure help you out.

Also know that this is bar none the best site for learning how to straight shave, and your next shave will be better (couldn't be worse unless you died trying!)