Thread: Beginners tips: May 2015

Everyone that has gotten into straight razor shaving inevitably gets involved with razor honing in one way or another. I see a lot of posts asking which hones are good beginner hones to start with. We have plenty of information on SRP regarding hones suitable for razors, however this information can be difficult to navigate sometimes. Let’s review some of the popular choices of hones and avenues that beginners should consider when getting into honing straight razors.

The majority of new straight razor shavers get their razors from online stores in shave ready condition so at least at the beginning, for a few months, there is no need to worry about edge maintenance other than stropping. Still, there comes a moment when the edge starts to tug a little bit and it needs to be refreshed. Let’s talk about what hones will work well in those situations.

For just maintenance of the edge one can use a single hone, a finishing hone such as the 12k Naniwa Super Stone for example. This synthetic hone works very well with all steels, it is fairly fast for a finisher and only a few passes will bring the edge back to shave ready.



12k Super Stone

We know all too well that once we get into the hobby, one razor is just not enough or ten for that matter. Many razors come from antique stores or auction sites, those razors are rarely shave ready, so a new edge has to be put on them. In general for making razors shave-ready one will need a bevel setting hone, two intermediate level hones, a finishing hone, and two strops. There are a variety of options at all those levels, I’ll list the ones that perform the best according to multiple accounts on the forum.

1. Bevel setting level
Naniwa Chosera 1k is the king. An alternative would be 1k Super stone or 1k Shapton Glass stone. The 1k Chosera is fast, cuts very uniformly, dishes slowly and is not too thirsty. Those qualities are really what a quality 1k hone should possess.



Naniwa Chosera 1k

2. Intermediate level
Several options are available in this range. Naniwa Super Stone 5k, Shapton Pro 5k, Shapton Glass 4k, Norton 4k. At this level it is really a matter of personal preference which hone to choose. One cannot go wrong with any of them. The 5k Super stone is a very consistent performer, it is fast and easy to use. I alternate that with a Sahpron Pro 5k. The Shapton Pro 5k is similar to the 5k Super Stone in performance; it is fast, very consistent and easy to use.

3. High intermediate level
At this level there are again several options all of which will produce very good results and are interchangeable. 8k Norton, 8k Naniwa Super Stone, 8k Shapton Pro, 8k Shapton Glass.



1/5/8/12k Naniwa Super Stones

4. Finishing level
The Naniwa 12k is touted as the undisputed finishing hone by many. It is a very consistent and fast hone that produces a great edge.

5. Strops
After the last hone in the progression, the razor will need a few passes on a pasted strop. The pasted strop can be either a bench strop, or a hanging strop, which kind is a matter of personal preference. After the pasted strop a hanging strop should be used to prepare the edge for the shave. There is a myriad of strops made from all kinds of leather out there. As long as the strop is quality made, the type of leather does not really matter for the edge. The different kinds of leather will feel different during stropping, so which type of leather to choose for one’s strop is another YMMV variable.



A tutorial how to make a paddle/bench strop can be found here(there are many others posted on the forum):
http://straightrazorpalace.com/works...-tutorial.html

The list above is a good reference of what to buy to be able to keep a razor in shave ready condition, or to make a razor shave ready. There are many other hones out there, a lot of them not very expensive and thus attractive for the beginner due to low cost of initial investment. However, if one is serious about honing their own blades, make sure to get a set of proven hones - this will save you money in the long run.

Finally, there are all kinds of natural hones out there, my advice for those new to honing: Forget about natural hones for the moment. Focus on mastering technique and improving results.

Nice work! Great advise, perhaps clarifying the 1st pic to description.

90% of what I know about honing I learned from Stefan. I don't hone for anyone else so it's not like my skills are legendary. But I can attest that his advice is worth taking. I always say, take the advice of one or two trusted individuals. Stefan is one of those.

Stefan,

Thanks for a good analysis of honing and the stone/hones. A good guide for the novice, or even the new/medium advanced honer!!

Regards, Howard

I have pretty much followed this route with the Naniwa 12k for refreshing then getting Naniwa 1, 5, 8k for honing. I am a complete novice but it has worked very well for me. There's a lot of satisfaction in getting a completely blunt razor shaving sweetly!

A perfect introduction to the world of honing for novices such as myself. Thanks.

Excellent post for the new shaver/honer

Thanks,

Jim

Great. 400 plus dollars spent on Arkansas stones and I see this.

I decided on and bought my hones as soon as I started SR shaving and was mostly swayed by my love of rocks and a thread I read on SRP. I do love sipping a bourbon and refreshing my razors on a fine translucent ark. Having said that; takes time and oil. I also had some of my razors sent out and they were pro-honed on Naniwa superstones. I looked at my maintained, arkie edge and the naniwa edges through a microscope. The Naniwa edges looked nearly perfect, my edge looked crude in comparison. Some of that would be my inexperience but those Naniwa edges looked amazing.
Just Monday I put my favorite razor on a hard ark and then finished it with the translucent. Couple of passes on pasted linen, stropped and had the best shave of my life. Something really satisfying about shaving off an edge you've maintained.
Great advice from the original poster!

Originally Posted by Paulbuck

Great. 400 plus dollars spent on Arkansas stones and I see this.

I decided on and bought my hones as soon as I started SR shaving and was mostly swayed by my love of rocks and a thread I read on SRP. I do love sipping a bourbon and refreshing my razors on a fine translucent ark. Having said that; takes time and oil. I also had some of my razors sent out and they were pro-honed on Naniwa superstones. I looked at my maintained, arkie edge and the naniwa edges through a microscope. The Naniwa edges looked nearly perfect, my edge looked crude in comparison. Some of that would be my inexperience but those Naniwa edges looked amazing.
Just Monday I put my favorite razor on a hard ark and then finished it with the translucent. Couple of passes on pasted linen, stropped and had the best shave of my life. Something really satisfying about shaving off an edge you've maintained.
Great advice from the original poster!

Nothing really wrong with the way you went. The reason I recommended the above-mentioned hones is that it is easier path to getting a good edge. Naturals can be tricky and IMHO are advanced honing topic. Again YMMV.

Excellent Post and advice to anyone wanting to hone their own. I think its a bullet proof start to any ones journey. I have been using either Chosera 1k Nani 3/8/12 or Norton 4/8 since my beginning and I get all I need from these rocks and it just gets better and better. Thanks for putting this out there. All new guys take this advice and success is around the corner.