Thanks for all the replies. I just shaved, after doing 10 laps on CO, 10 on Diamond, 10 on Scrub, and 50 on clean leather. I paid special attention to the angle keeping it low and light. Unfortunately, it basically did just scrape off the lather on the WTG pass. The ATG was tugging and pulling. I have 2 other razors that I bought used currently being sharpened by Lynn, so when those come back, I'll at least have something to compare against. Until then, I'll keep stropping and working on my technique, and finishing up with DE until I get this down.