Don't go the AOS route! Save your money. I agree that you should go to Tony at the wellshavedgentleman. If you buy a #1 strop, you can pick up a very nice practice strop for only $5 (I think that's the deal). That way you learn on a cheaper strop and won't nick your better one. Once you're proficient, you can move to the #1 strop and use the other for travel, etc.

I also live in NY and have never had a problem with rust. I don't even oil them. I use the alcohol as described already and store them in a wooden drawer in the living room. No problems. Good luck and have fun!

Jordan