The orginal posting sounded like something I would have written before I took up straight shaving.

My bottom line straight is a Dovo Tortoise, which shaves well and takes an edge well. All of my other Dovo's are top of the line and work very well. Most of these were purchased new.

This may sound strange, but don't put too much emphasis on the first straight as you will likely end up with more than one. Plus all the other variables - shave soap, brush, and face prep make a big difference in the performance of the shave.

Good Luck,

Pabster