So it looks like I will be sending one (or all) of these guys off soon! I'm happy to know that they are all razors that can actually hold an edge and not some cheap crazy knockoff. Looks like my dad got pretty lucky, since he got the whole lot of six for like $30!

So the hunt is on for a honester! I've PM'd Jhenry for the email of the honester he knows who is located near me, but I am open to all suggestions so that I can weigh my options.

I looked at both strops that red96ta mentioned and I think I will start with the philly. It fits my current budget better and I have no problem upgrading to a nicer one once I get the hang of this and decide it is definitely for me.

Once again, thanks to everyone for their replies and advice! Can't wait to get the ball rolling on this!