Thread: help with my first straight

The dealer more likely dulled it more than he sharpened it. You at least seem to recognize there is a difference between honing a razor and honing a knife so you are off to a great start!
I have held a Hen and Rooster, but have never honed or shaved with one. I will gladly hone it for free except for the price of postage just for the opportunity to try one. Send me a PM if interested.
Regarding the toe of the blade, if the corner comes to a sharp 90 degree angle, that is called a spike point. If it is very slightly rounded, that is a square point. A spike can be muted (dulled) so that it does not cut, without altering the aesthetics of the blade. This just takes a couple of light strokes on the side of a hone.