Last week this thread really wet my appetite for a new bay rum. I ordered the Ogallala sample pack. How is it that I've never tried Ogallala before. Wow, these are some bold aftershaves. Really,really nice. BUT they are not really bay rum. They are wonderful scents but not what you'd expect for a bay rum. Great stuff. But what one will I reorder? Tough to say. The cedar and sage seems to be in front but the lime peppercorn is great too. If you haven't tried Ogallala, give the sample pack a shot. You'll be as undecided as i am.