HELP! HVAC & Regulatory Capture

[JBHoren]

I have a 2-ton, Goodman split-system A/C: condenser outside, air handler inside -- installed 5/2012. The condenser "died" this past July, and I had it replaced (same A/C contractor as before) with a newer unit (the previous condenser was discontinued, and no replacement coil available). Works like a champ -- for $2,500 it had better.

Problem: He didn't pull a permit. WTF not? Because in order to obtain a permit, my municipality requires that both parts be replaced with "compatible" units. But the air handler works fine! (if it ain't broke, why "fix" it?).

Nope. The municipality says both units have to be listed as "compatible" on the AHRI (Air Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute) tables... and these aren't. Now, the AHRI doesn't perform its own testing; it gets tables of matching units from the manufacturers. But... the manufacturers only test units within given "families" of their product lines -- not between actually-compatible, "cross-family" units of their own product lines.

I called the AHRI -- they refused to speak with me... only with manufacturers.
I called Goodman -- they refused to connect me with Technical Support (only for "in-the-trade")

So, this is another example of regulatory capture. That is, the municipality wants to "protect" me/us from "unscrupulous" or "unknowing" individuals (think: fly-by-night roofs and driveways). The inspector isn't an HVAC engineer or vo-tech school graduate, nor was he ever an HVAC employee. Neither is his boss. OTOH, my contractor is -- a vo-tech school graduate, state-certified, with 20+ years hands-on experience in HVAC... and he knows Goodman (he's one of their distributors) and he knows what's compatible.

How can I fight City Hall... and win? The new, "compatible" air handler will cost me $2,000 installed.

Original condenser: Goodman VSX130241
Original air handler: Goodman AWUF240516
New condenser: Goodman GSXM402410AA

[32t]

regulatory capture My new term for the day.

I have experienced this but have not heard it stated this way.

Can you argue that they must prove that the evaporator is not "compatible" with the condenser?

[JBHoren]

regulatory capture My new term for the day.

I have experienced this but have not heard it stated this way.

Google "Professional Managerial Class" -- it's what/who run the country, not the politicians. Every law that's legislated (at the federal, state, and local level) spawns dozens (often hundreds) of regulations. That's the Deep State.

Can you argue that they must prove that the evaporator is not "compatible" with the condenser?

That would be my choice, but my guess is that their approach is: "If they're not listed as compatible, then they're not compatible."

[sharptonn]

Pray, how did the city know the condenser unit had been changed?
Also, an air handler 21 years old may not even be 'compatability considered' in current MFG charts. They DO want you to do both at once! Whether you need it or not.
Would be a call for comparing of specifications/experience. It's done all the time!

[JBHoren]

Pray, how did the city know the condenser unit had been changed?

Inspectors "cruise" condo developments and place ID codes (sticker or marking) on outside units. When they discover a new (unmarked) one, they check for a record of the permit. So, new condenser w/no ID marking...

Also, an air handler 21 years old may not even be 'compatability considered' in current MFG charts. They DO want you to do both at once! Whether you need it or not.

11 years-old, not 21. Again, the original pair were "charted" as compatible -- that's all that matters... they could be 20 years-old, but all that counts is this "compatibility" at time of installation.

Would be a call for comparing of specifications/experience. It's done all the time!

Yup, they could compare old (current) air handler and new condenser specs to see, but they only want AHRI-supplied tabular data. "That ain't workin', that's the way ya do it; money for nuthin' and yer chicks for free."

[outback]

Send um a picture of his kid, and ask if the multi colored, and mixed matched clothing he's wearing is not compatible with u and God the creator. Attach it to the letter and return it back to him.