Trying to decide on my first hunting rifle
Growing up in suburban Canada, my parents, and grandparents, had no use for firearms, nor any interest in hunting. My grandfather had an old 22 that he used on the farm later in life just for critter control, but I never really even saw or shot the gun.
Anyhow, I've long wanted to hunt but haven't really known anyone who did, or even how to get into the sport - that was until this year. I've met a few friends who hunt deer and who would be willing to go with me next year. Being in Canada, I need to take my firearms safety course to get a Possession and Acquisition License (PAL) and also take the Ontario Hunter Safety Course to get my deer tags. Thankfully, the government makes this easy with a "One-Stop" course that is offered in a single weekend and you can get both your licenses at the same time.
I'll be taking the course in mid-December and should have all the paperwork processed to go purchase a rifle in February sometime (I don't really care about the wait, but just mention it to give you all an idea that I'm not really pressed to make a decision any time soon). That said, I've started thinking about what I'd want in a rifle, mainly for deer hunting, but also for the occasional moose or caribou hunt. My buddy has a Browning X-Bolt Stainless Stalker 308 Win, and he's adamant that he'd never by another non-stainless rifle again since cleaning and maintenance are a breeze.
All of the guys in the hunting group use 308 so that they can swap ammo if needed, and they said they prefer the 308 because it has the stopping power for moose or caribou and also won't obliterate deer if shot at a closer range.
Seeing as how I know virtually nothing about rifles, and have only ever shot 4 guns in my life, I'd like to hear your opinions and suggestions.
Thanks in advance,
Mark
Chambering is fine, but...
Hi Milton.
Most hunters are probably more skilled than I. The marksmanship portion is well handled, but tracking/stalking is marginal. I say that to let you know right away there are few experts on the topic. Perhaps a gray-haired professional guide would be best there.
308 is okay, but getting marginal for moose. Its a fav chambering for me, largely because of the accuracy. I would rather something larger for moose, but the larger cartridge will make it less pleasant for all other hunting or shooting. Perhaps the biggest obstacle for the larger cartridge is that recoil will be enough to make you think before going out for what would be enough practice to gain marksmanship proficiency. It's one thing to have a marginal shot on paper - another thing altogether when hitting game. I'm not speaking here of the danger side - although that would come into play w/ the bull moose, but just giving due care and ethics of killing something. I have no prob. w/ killing something to eat. I have a prob w/ anything that would not be eaten, or if it can't be taken with a very fast, humane ending.
Rule 1: reliable shot placement trumps all discussion of which cartridge.
To gain this proficiency, you needn't constantly tenderize your shoulder by blowing heavy hunting loads for practice. The truth is that you can learn every portion of riflery with the humble .22 with the possible exception of learning to handle recoil. Several thousand rounds of high quality practice w/ a 22 and then maybe 1-300 w/ a centerfire will do way more for you than buying a beautiful trophy super boom stick, that you will then beat up by dragging it through the woods and fields. I'd rather shoot a moose w/ a 308 (with the right projectile) and be able to place a perfect shot than a cannon w/ marginal shot placement.
The other areas of hunting skills, I must leave to my betters - I'm not qualified to talk about the tracking & stalking. I tend to make up for lack of ability to close into a near shot by marksmanship.
I hope you enjoy it very much, and especially can pass the love of the sport to your children.
'good input, good attitudes.
Milt, it sound like the people here want you to succeed and enjoy. I'm one of them.
All best of luck.
A lifetime ago, when I did a lot of varmint shooting...
I also hand loaded all my shells. While factory ammunition is extremely consistent, I never knew anyone who shot recreationally that didn't hand load.
That was 25 years ago. Of the three of us who shot together, I had a Remington 6mm, another of us had an array of Remington .223 weapons, and one of us had an old piece of crap JC Higgins 30-06.
We all hand loaded, and the variety of components available in 30 caliber is astounding. That 30-06 cartridge can be loaded to do more, and less, than almost any other commercially available caliber. Man, could that guy hit with that 30-06 of his.
The only drawback to varmint shooting with the 30-06 is the sheer volume of powder it took.
I'd guess a .308 cartridge can be made to do just about anything the 30-06 cartridge can do.
What to get? I'd get the '-06 in a modern bolt action rifle, for no other reason than cartridge availability. But, that's just me.