Thuringian?

[dmnc]

Does this look like a thuringian to you guys?
301686663125 ebay number. I have never even held one yet. Seller says he thinks is an escher rather than a thuringian. Eschers are all thuringian so am looking for some expert opinions.

[cosperryan]

to me it looks like a Chinese stone. But I don't have any experience with thuringian so I couldn't really say if it looks like one. All I know is it looks like a beat up version of my Chinese.

[DaveW]

Possible, but I wouldn't risk it for the price. Could be any number of slates (including the chinese stones). If it had an old beat up remnant of a label on one end, I'd be more inclined to take the risk. It does look fine cutting, but you never know until you get it.

[Euclid440]

Escher’s are Thüringen’s, with an Escher label.

It can only be claimed to be an Escher, if it has a label, otherwise it’s a Thüringen. Although I have seen some guys on eBay list a greasy black Carborundum stones as “Escher?” The label does not necessarily make it a better or finer stone, than an unlabeled Thüringen or will produce better edges. It’s just a rock, you still have to do the work.

And it is almost impossible to tell for sure, from a photo, if it is a Thüringen or just a slate stone.

So buyer beware, as a blue green, Thüringen, it is a bit pricy for me, quite a bit. On the other hand, I have bought Thüringen’s at flea markets and Garge sales for a buck or two.

Here are 2 Thüringens, a blue/ green and dark blue and a Translucent Ark, I bought recently for $21 at an antique flea market.

They are out there, find them.

[hatzicho]

From the pictures it could well be a thuringian hone. Some typical characteristics, begining from the fine surface with white scratches, the glassy look when wet to the sawmarks would fit.
Stone is described as very hard? which would absolutely not fit for a thuri.
To the question Escher or not I think I have said enough throughout all my posts.

All in all - for a low price I would take a chance on it (300 sloty is about 72 €)

[dmnc]

Cheers for helpful replies. Don't think will take the chance for the price. May try one of the smaller ones on offer at the mo, slightly wary of the size, one inch wide doesn't sound very easy to hone with