Thread: Coticule

Hi Guys, Quick newbie question if I may.

I want to touch up my razors because my collection is growing and it will get expensive to send them off too often.

I understand that it isn't recommended to start honing at my experience but unless a honer moves in next door I need to learn to touch up.

Anyway, are these worth considering?

https://www.ebay.ca/itm/Selected-Bel...sAAOSwrVRdqL-E

or

https://www.ebay.ca/itm/Franz-Swaty-...E/113939443288

Thanks for your assistance guys.

Steve

The working area of the Swaty is clean but the shipping on that makes it a no go. It would have to sell for under $20 or so to make it cheap enough to offset that shipping. The coticule has crazy shipping too. For a refresh hone that is easy to use, you can get a Naniwa 12K from Paul’s finest. If you get to doing restore works it will fit in better there. If you think you want to try a barber hone out then perhaps put a want ad in the classifieds. There are a lot of guys with boxes of barber hone stashed away that will likely let them go for less than ebay.

+1 to the 12k synthetic. Will want something to keep it flat as well. Coticule can be a great option if you get a good one buttttt, everyone is looking for a great one and chances are you won't get a finishing one.

Yup. Probably two of the most controversial and hardest stones to learn to get a good edge on.

Most barber hones are in the 6k range and the small size make it difficult for a new honer to learn on. As said most guys have a box of them. They do make great Ax or backpack knife stones.

Coticules are all over the map, proof is almost no one owns just one. Everyone is looking for one that delivers a “Better” finish.

Don’t know that seller, though the Natural Coticules look nicer. The one linked is small. If I was buying a Coticule, I would buy a Natural over a glued stone, I have had better luck with natural stones over glued stones.

A 12k Naniwia is a much better, no brainer, almost guaranteed edge producer.

With a little bit of experimentation one can get smoking edges from it. I just posted how I max out a 12k edge from a Super Stone on this thread.

The almighty Naniwa 12k


.

don't know about the Swaty , but that coti looks like a 'la nouvelle veine' . Most of these are quite fast on water but dead slow on water so merely polishing...check out coticule.be for more info - price is not too bad either.

Originally Posted by bartds

don't know about the Swaty , but that coti looks like a 'la nouvelle veine' . Most of these are quite fast on water but dead slow on water so merely polishing...check out coticule.be for more info - price is not too bad either.

Not sure about nouvelle veine, I contacted ardennes for 5 years in a row inquiring about that vein and they weren't mining, nor had plans to do so in the near future they told me.

I hope I'm wrong because it's an excellent vein



The smaller one in the picture is without a doubt a La Grise

Sorry to bother you again about this guys.

This looks just right to me but I thought I would run it by you all first.

https://www.ebay.ca/itm/NATURAL-FINE...cxTuiakHRDSWiw

Price seems good to me as well, about $31 Canadian inc shipping from UK

Steve

I have one of those purple Welsh slates.
There's lots of info on here about them, so use the search bar for everyones opinions.
Personally I quite like mine, I lapped one side to a high grit and use Smith's honing solution for about 30ish feather light laps. It gives crisp edge.
I use the other side with a DMT card to create a light slurry then go to the high grit side if the edge is not quite ready for a finisher.

As mentioned your better of biting the bullet and get the 12k Naniwa, they cut fast and are easy to use.

Originally Posted by markbignosekelly

I have one of those purple Welsh slates.
There's lots of info on here about them, so use the search bar for everyones opinions.
Personally I quite like mine, I lapped one side to a high grit and use Smith's honing solution for about 30ish feather light laps. It gives crisp edge.
I use the other side with a DMT card to create a light slurry then go to the high grit side if the edge is not quite ready for a finisher.

As mentioned your better of biting the bullet and get the 12k Naniwa, they cut fast and are easy to use.

Hi, I have bought it. My thinking is that it's only about $30 Canadian delivered so if it's good I have a real bargain.

If it's bad then I haven't lost much.

I will get a 12k Naniwa eventually but I'm still a bit new and there are people that will think I'm mad even trying to use a stone yet. But, I just can't succumb to my RAD if I don't even try to refresh the blades and send them less often.

Never know, I might be able to learn to hone my own blades eventually!

As it happens I am English like you and we know that the good slate is from welsh Wales

Steve

Listing says two things that dont go together.
Natural and 12k.
Natural stones dont have a grit rating! That is hs opinion not fact.