Thread: Substitute for barbers hone

Could this be used like a barbers hone? Buy Natural Water Stone 8 x 2 x 1 at Woodcraft

Originally Posted by EucrisBoy

Could this be used like a barbers hone? Buy Natural Water Stone 8 x 2 x 1 at Woodcraft

Those, often called the C12k or sometimes the PHIG, tend to be slow and vary in quality. Some make great finishers, others say they are not. I have had 3 and really liked the shaves off each. Any finisher can be used for maintenance, but a slow finisher will take more strokes.

In short, it depends on how you planned to use a barber's hone...

Originally Posted by holli4pirating

Those, often called the C12k or sometimes the PHIG, tend to be slow and vary in quality. Some make great finishers, others say they are not. I have had 3 and really liked the shaves off each. Any finisher can be used for maintenance, but a slow finisher will take more strokes.

In short, it depends on how you planned to use a barber's hone...

I want to use it to refresh and finish an edge.

To finish, yes. To refresh, yes, though the number of strokes will depend on how long you wait.

A hallmark of barber hones is that they are fast; these tend to not be. But it can work.

I have one of those PHIGs on the way, I'll let you know how mine "refreshes" in a week or two.

I think a barber hone would be a good substitute for a barber hone. You can get them for the same price, and the barber hone will do exactly what the barber hone is supposed to do, with no additional hoops to jump through. Well, I guess you might have to clean it up first. You're gonna end up with both anyways, by the time it's all said and done. Both, and then some more....and then a few extras..and maybe another one.

Originally Posted by regularjoe

I think a barber hone would be a good substitute for a barber hone.

Now Joe, I know it's New Years, but you've got me concerned !! LOL! That's one I would make!! HAPPY NEW YEAR BUDDY!!!

Howard.

Yeah, I shouldn't have posted Howard. lol. I was saying just get a barber hone. No reason to complicate things by getting something that "could" do the same thing. Just get the barber hone, cause everybody knows it WILL do the same thing. lol Happy new year to you as well.

Well never mind I guess, I got an Carborundum Axolite 200 barbers hone. Now all I need is a pasted strop and a Norton 4k/8k.

You might think about just working with that ALoxite for a couple months, and see what you can make it do before you decide to get some more gear. You might just master that little bugger, and discover that all you needed was some more time, practice, and experience. Ofc, that's a YMMV, IMHO, and FWIW depending on your mileage. :P