So going by feel only, you should be feeling a 1K edge but less rough/thick/harsh edge. Not shaveable by any means. Lets say you did it correctly.
Stop and look at the stria now.
Now move to your next stone.
After 50 strokes look at it again.
Stria should be shallower looking. More important edge should feel keener.
What stones are you using?? This is an important question as to how stria will appear. Cotis and circles strokes obliterate stria quickly.
Synthetics and x strokes only will result in shallower stria and/or a shiner edge than you had.
Lastly check your tape for wear, and inspect to make sure that you only have a single bevel.
I find that being under an overhead light and the loupe I see better. Best is a lighted loupe