Help.....!!!

Having successfully renewed the cutting edge on my Cadman last month I decided I needed to refresh the edge last night. I knew I didn't need to get the stones out, I especially knew that incorporating the Welsh DT was unnecessary and a mistake, yet I persisted. Disaster. Now I have a dull, very dull, razor. It's so dull I could lick it. Panicking and tired (it was late), I decided a desperate situation called for decisive and bold action; taking the razor I ran the edge across the glass handle of the Pyrex glass jug containing the water, now I was in uncharted waters! Whipping up a muddy surface with the slurry stone I set to work, Lynne on the iPad beside me, attempting to reset the bevel that I by now considered lost, but it was to no avail. Thirty minutes later I admitted defeat.

Current situation: One dull as dirt Cadman Bengall. Tools: Dragons Tongue, PHIG, red and black pasted strop. Skill Level: Clark Griswold.

Question: What stone would you recommend I obtain to rescue the situation, would a Naniwa 1 or 2 k be best here?