Thread: Taping the spine

The whole reason I stay away from diamond hones

Originally Posted by outback

The whole reason I stay away from diamond hones

I have 1k, 4K, 8k Norton and 12k Naniwa SS

Steve

Originally Posted by STF

I have 1k, 4K, 8k Norton and 12k Naniwa SS

Steve

That’s a pretty complete starter set with which to learn good honing technique.

Take your time; watch a bunch of good honing videos (Glen Gssixgun has a bunch and he explains what he does very clearly) and check the edge as you go.

STAY FOCUSED, GO SLOW AND GO SMOOTH. I’ve had to go back to the 1K stone more often than I care to admit because I screwed up a single lap on a higher grit stone and messed up the bevel as a result.

Strop a bunch after honing.

Don’t go to the stones unless you really have to. If your razor starts to tug or underperform, try stropping first and/or a few light laps on the barber hone or a pasted strop before you decide to go back to the stones. Many of us hone way more than we need to simply maintain a shave ready edge.

The more you hone, the less razor you have.

One tip I have learned along the way to reduce tape residue is to make sure no water is present on the blade when you apply a new layer. Buff that spine a bit. That and really peeling off the tape, not pulling it off at a 90 deg angle, if that makes any lick of sense.

“I know jointing is a common remedy for that situation, but I have never understood the reason when going to the next stone will remove that burr. Just always seemed excessive & like creating more work to me.”

Jointing makes a straight edge, much like jointing an edge of a board. It cut off the burr. If you look straight down on the edge after jointing, you may see black spots on the shiny line of the new straight edge.

The black dots are chip that were not fully removed. That says a lot about the edge. A lot depends on the condition and the quality of the steel. If the edge has been worked, shaped or buffed then it is common to get a rough edge and all the roughness will have to be removed to the depth of the deepest chip.

You can hone it all out, or you can just cut it off. It is easier and more efficient, to cut it off straight, than to hope you hone it off evenly. With most all edge tools, jointing is a common practice, to begin sharpening with a straight edge. One can hone the edge straight, either way the same amount of material will need to be removed.

Jointing removes less, as the edge is already straight, and you just need to get the bevels to meet. If the bevels were set, flat and in the correct plane, you only need to get them to meet, a matter of 10-20 laps.

Dragging the edge on a non-abrasive object, tears the burr off and does not cut it off cleanly, creating micro chipping. Yes, we are talking about microns here, but the goal is efficient honing of a straight edge, how ever you get there.

Originally Posted by Euclid440

“I know jointing is a common remedy for that situation, but I have never understood the reason when going to the next stone will remove that burr. Just always seemed excessive & like creating more work to me.”

Jointing makes a straight edge, much like jointing an edge of a board. It cut off the burr. If you look straight down on the edge after jointing, you may see black spots on the shiny line of the new straight edge.

The black dots are chip that were not fully removed. That says a lot about the edge. A lot depends on the condition and the quality of the steel. If the edge has been worked, shaped or buffed then it is common to get a rough edge and all the roughness will have to be removed to the depth of the deepest chip.

You can hone it all out, or you can just cut it off. It is easier and more efficient, to cut it off straight, than to hope you hone it off evenly. With most all edge tools, jointing is a common practice, to begin sharpening with a straight edge. One can hone the edge straight, either way the same amount of material will need to be removed.

Jointing removes less, as the edge is already straight, and you just need to get the bevels to meet. If the bevels were set, flat and in the correct plane, you only need to get them to meet, a matter of 10-20 laps.
I still don't see the advantage. If the bevels ares properly set it takes about 3 strokes to remove the burr on the next stone, maybe a couple more in extreme cases.

Dragging the edge on a non-abrasive object, tears the burr off and does not cut it off cleanly, creating micro chipping. Yes, we are talking about microns here, but the goal is efficient honing of a straight edge, how ever you get there.
For me it's not about tearing the edge off , rather folding it to one side so the stone can cut it off.

I always use fast cutting stones & /or small progression jumps & rarely feel a need to joint an edge. Possibly that colours my opinion.

Originally Posted by onimaru55

I always use fast cutting stones & /or small progression jumps & rarely feel a need to joint an edge. Possibly that colours my opinion.

I do the same. Never had a problem with burrs