Gentlemen,
This has been a very interesting debate so far. Some great ideas in here, too. To give everybody the chance to re-assess their positions (and maybe read up on previous discussions around the same topic, of which there are quite a few really good ones), I am closing this thread for a few hours.
Thank you for your understanding,
Robin
[Edit] Thread is re-opened. Please let us have your arguments in a gentlemanly fashion.