I agree with Hal, mastery of one type of stones does not an expert make of all stones. I find the barber hones to be very frustrating, yet extremely satisfying when a blade turns out good. It almost makes me feel like I've gained a better appreciation for the skillset that my Grandfathers had. I don't think it really matters what you use, as long as you spend the time and thought to reach the skill level needed to hone razors. To each their own. I value the experiences of all, as that always gives me a perspective that I might have missed.

Rexj