Thread: I'm not sure what to say about this.

All this talk about people shaving with knives and axes, i thought (for a laugh) i would give it a go myself... So i honed up one of my kitchen knives, stropped and shaved.. Not a bad shave either.. i little awkward but not bad! lol - Video attached



...... Only if i had an axe!

Great video. 2 collar and cuffs in the bathroom as well.

Thanks, That's 2 x slings from a shoulder reconstruction i had a few months ago.. probably should throw it out now lol

Has anyone actually tried his edge? Most of you folks are true mockery masters.

"He who does things other way than ours, is worth nothing but laughter and pity." You should add that motto right below the logo. And consider changing the name to Straight Razor Hate. For real.

Matt

Originally Posted by matisso

Has anyone actually tried his edge? Most of you folks are true mockery masters.

"He who does things other way than ours, is worth nothing but laughter and pity." You should add that motto right below the logo. And consider changing the name to Straight Razor Hate. For real.

Matt

I don't think anybody has, but the reason is that Carter Cutlery does not offer the service. If he did I'm pretty sure a number of us would love to experience his edges and make our own judgment.

With all that has already been said here, I imagine that he'd gladly hone a few razors for comparisons, even if he officially doesn't offer the service. Any man who believes he's good at what he's doing would do so. But there will always be an excuse...

Best defend by attacking, eh? Somehow that kind trolling is fine with you?:

Originally Posted by Magpie

Would it be terrible to admit.... I kind of Enjoy bashing Mr. Carter? Hes kind of fun to put on the whipping post!

Now, that's a good piece of constructive criticism, and surely a valuable addition....

Originally Posted by matisso

I imagine that he'd gladly hone a few razors for comparisons, even if he officially doesn't offer the service.

Over 24 hours ago, I posted a Video Response on youtube to Mr. Carter. He has not approved it for display on his video yet. In the video, I offer to send him a german straight razor much like the one that he uses, with my shave ready edge on it. After he tries it, I ask him to send it back to me with his edge on it so that I can experience it.

Like I said, nothing yet. Hopefully he posts it. Until then, you can find it, just search Response to Carter Cutlery Razor Sharpening

Originally Posted by matisso

With all that has already been said here, I imagine that he'd gladly hone a few razors for comparisons, even if he officially doesn't offer the service.

Any man who believes he's good at what he's doing would do so. But there will always be an excuse...

Until he actually does it will be indeed only in your imagination. There isn't a lack of invitations, and things in real life take longer than posting on the internet, so you will do well to not rush to a judgment as a knee jerk reaction to somebody else's rush of judgment.

Originally Posted by matisso

Best defend by attacking, eh? Somehow that kind trolling is fine with you?

No, it's not fine with me, but contrary to what you may think, this isn't a police state and we generally allow members, just like we have been allowing you to make mistakes. To a point, of course.

Originally Posted by matisso

Has anyone actually tried his edge? Most of you folks are true mockery masters.

"He who does things other way than ours, is worth nothing but laughter and pity." You should add that motto right below the logo. And consider changing the name to Straight Razor Hate. For real.

Matt

Matt:
Most everyone here that is worth his weight in hones has tried just about every system and stroke you could possibly imagine , we know from years of experience, that a finish stroke using a back hone motion on a 6k hone is not nearly what most any accomplished or even semi-accomplished honer will settle for, or anywhere near as smooth as most straight razor shavers will settle for ...

Honing a straight razor as though it is a knife, resulted in, by his own words "An inferior shave"...

There is no "New" or interesting system or technique being presented in this Vid it is just an tried and proved inferior way of honing straight razors...
Basically most everyone honing razors can beat that edge and never pick up more than a Barber's Hone... Do you understand now???? That it is the system that is lacking here, not the honer...

Originally Posted by matisso

Has anyone actually tried his edge? Most of you folks are true mockery masters.

"He who does things other way than ours, is worth nothing but laughter and pity." You should add that motto right below the logo. And consider changing the name to Straight Razor Hate. For real.

Matt

What a pity you don't understand or appreciate the history of SRP. If you did you would realise just how ridiculous your statement is.

James.