Quote Originally Posted by unit View Post
I agree with what you say, but would go a step further and add knowing where to draw the lines between what is a touch up, a full honing, and edge restoration.

I say "edge" restoration in efforts to simplify a bit. Surely full restoration of the razor (pins, slabs, faces and tang) is another level of complexity. But just under the moniker of "edge" you may deal with frown correction, chips, warps, and a myriad of types of corrosion.

Every flea market razor I pick up seems to teach me more and more about these concepts. Knowing what NOT to buy is a skill in itself! (I have intentionally bought some steamers just for the sake of pushing my learning and skill building).
I absolutely agree - edge assessment as you describe, and even further: knowing when a razor will not take or hold an edge. For example, if Glen told you that your razor will not take or hold an edge, you'd feel fairly confident he was right (albeit disappointed), whereas you may want a second opinion on that kind of diagnosis if given by someone with less experience and skill.

And for the record, I am with you all the way on the what not to buy issue. Nowadays I don't buy bad geometry at all. I figure life's too short when all I'm doing is buying for myself.

James.