"Peppermint Clove" - This one is guaranteed to warm up you face. It doesn't get quite as warm as Captain's Choice - Cat o' Nine Tails" though. My wife loves peppermint, so this one is a close top on her list. I rate it lower than the others, but it is still nice. I would wear it, but not nearly as frequently as the 1911.

So far I have to give them high marks as I do not dislike any of their aftershaves. I will give the last one a shot tomorrow or the day after.

~Gary