Sensitive skin guy here. I am a big fan of fake-Thayers Witch Hazel with aloe. Nothing wrong with Thayers, by the way, but I fill the empty bottle 2/3 with generic witch hazel, several tablespoons (by eye) of cold-processed aloe, a couple of ounces of isopropyl alcohol (optional) and some essense/scent (optional). I have very happy with 30-drops of lemon essence per bottle.

Nice on the skin after a shave, the scent (or not) of your choice, dries fast, cheap.