Thread: W.M. Neumann's aftershave splash reviews

No, I doubt anyone will end up buying the whole line. I went in for the 1911 and Peppermint/Clove. And I got a puck of the bay rum since I love bay rum. I used the 1911 this mornign...early, at about 5AM. I can still smell it on me. Its got a great balance in that the scent's power is tamed down to allow you to splash it on but it doesn't blow off your face 10 minutes later. Most A/S is one extreme or the other. My DR Harris Sandalwood is great but its too strong to splash on. A few drops will be sufficient but then you can't really get the A/S effect of spalshing it on. Then there is most Bay Rum that evaporates into thin air after 15 minutes....which is good for bay rum since I don't want to walk around with a strong bay rum scent all day. Anyway, its a good, thoughtful lineup that offers some variety. I will be re-ordering when my supplies dwindle. Might try the Heartwood or 1904.

If you like sandlewood type scents, go for the heartwood for sure. I will be getting the full size of this one; it's easily become my new favorite splash, and I don't like sandlewood at all...go figure, but it's balance and clean scent are just spot on.

I felt that, the soda pop one aside, they all had merit. I could see enjoying all of them. And none of the products irritate my skin. As much as I like the scents of certain Truefitt and Hill products, they cause a reaction with my skin. Hopefully others will enjoy them too.