Here is what I think of these products, of course this is just my opinion. Let me start off by saying I have dry scent sensitive skin, so some of these After Shaves work better for me and others are just ok. I also have been using shaving soap, I have all the Nancy Boy shaving creams but lately I've been mesmerized by MWF and MdC. So my opinions are based after shaving with those soaps.

Cooling Gel: They say its for Normal-Oiler skin. I believe that cause it works so-so for me and it's my least favorite of the line but like I said before I have dry scent sensitive skin. It feels like an Oil and it smells ok (Lavender, Peppermint & Rosemary) but the shaving cream smells a lot better. It kind of burns my skin when I first apply it but that quickly ends. It makes my skin feel just ok. MWF or MdC + Cooling Gel =

Replenishing Gel: They say it's for sensitive or dryer skin. Works good for me and I use it when my skin is feeling raw/damaged from too much face lathering or when my skin is just in bad shape. Smells like straight up Cucumber, that all I can smell, just natural Cucumber. It also has Rose Hip oil and Witch Hazel. It feels like a balm and if I use too much my face feels sticky. I think I've used this the most, so I guess I really like it. MWF or MdC + Replenishing Gel =

Blossom Wood: They say all skin types. I've saved the best for last. When paired with the matching shaving cream it's good but when paired with MWF or MdC it's outstanding. We all know how good those shaving soaps are alone but when you add the Blossom Wood, it takes it up a notch. It feels like a cream and the scent is a woodsy, floral & citrus sort of thing. Which is good but I can get burnt out on it sort of fast. So I use it for awhile and then take a break from it. If I use too much my skin feels sort of greasy but when I use just the right amount my skin feels very soft and moisturized all day long. MWF or MdC + Blossom Wood =

I'm sure by next month I'll be a fanboy of something else but for now I really like the Nancy Boy after shave line and have been using it for about 6 months. Oh...I almost forgot....YMMV