I just picked up some CO Bigelow, I am looking forward to trying it. I have had some good shaves with SRD soaps. I love the India Bay scent.

SWMBO seems to like the organic stuff from etsy and local soap merchants, I on the other hand think most of these people seem to spend very little time trying to develop real lather that stays. Their soap smells nice but is basically soap packaged for shaving with no thought given to how long the lather should last