Thanks for all the responses, guys! It has proved at least somewhat enlightening. No small task, considering the rambling manner of my OP.

Lacking fun money at the moment, I just replaced the balm with a fresh bottle. For reference, the AS & cologne are both in the $15 neighborhood at the local stores. Still haven't found the soap lol.

Follow-up question: Is the scent virtually the same from cologne to AS to bar soap (those that remember it)??