Originally Posted by
LawsonStone
I recently took delivery of the Captain's Choice Bay Rum as well as their "Cat o Nine Tails" product. I liked the Bay Rum okay, though I don't find it notably better than Dominica. As for the Co9T, honestly, I don't know why there is so much excitement over the "burn." Dominica has a much stronger initial burn than the Co9T. The latter does hang on a while, but not so much as to merit, in my judgment, putting it in the permanent rotation. I will use up this bottle before making a final judgment, but for me, Cat o' Nine Tails is not a keeper. Not bad, just not sufficiently noteworthy to keep buying. The Captains Choice Bay Rum Aftershave is pretty nice, but again, I'm not immediately struck that it's a cut above the other better bay rums I've tried. So far, my favorites remain Dominica and Turtle Bay.