I'm not sure how useful this bit of info is. I just picked up off of eBay a vintage 1960's Avon Bay Rum after shave. Very similar to Clubman but with an understandably mellower aroma. I mainly wanted this to add to my BR collection because of the painted bottle that looks like a barrel. Also, now on it's way is an unopened bottle of vintage 1981 Avon Bay Rum Anniversary Keepsake. I don't expect it to differ much from the other Avon, but it will a nice addition to my future Bay Rum "museum".