Favorite grocery store aftershave (which is where this thread started I think) would be Old Spice original. Yes I think the formula has changed but I started using Old Spice when the bottles were real ceramic. Opps, dated myself a little, yet it is funny now many keep coming back to it.

Bay Rum, Meehan's from Bonny Dune Farms, is my favorite but I use them all. I added some glycerine to the St Pinuad and it help richin it up a bit.

Will be ordering the Ogallala special reserve soon, and will have to try Capt Smiths.