Thread: Saint Charles Shave New Spice Vs. Bay Rum?

Any preferences from those who have tried both?

Originally Posted by JLStorm

Any preferences from those who have tried both?

JL,

I've used em both. My preference...totally depends on my mood...both are great!

rt

New Spice is great. It lathers and lubricates
really well and I love the scent. If anyone
is partial to rose scents do give this a try.

I plan on ordering the Ginger Lime and Sandalwood
within the next few weeks. I'm trying to rein myself
in from aquiring too many soaps and creams.

In addition to the two above mentioned I also have
Taylor's Lavender cream, Trumpers Violet cream
Classic coconut and Classic fresh lime.



Terry

As everyone agrees, fragrances are highly subjective. I didn't care for the new spice cologne I bought. I haven't tried her bay rum, though I would bet that it's great. In fact, I'd quite like to get rid of the cologne...it's the small size (4oz) spray bottle. I tried, in the 'buy/sell/trade' forum to trade something for it, but had no responses. So if anyone's interested, I still have it. If no one has anything they'd like to trade for it, I'll let it go for shipping costs.

I recieved the new spice in the wood bowl yesterday. My wife and friends loved the smell which was a major plus!!!It lathers real quick and felt great.
I definetly would recommend this to everyone,and I will try the other scents.
I want to find at most 5 soaps/creams so I can have options depending on the mood or occasion.

I have not tried the spice, but I have used the bay rum soap and aftershave balm. I HIGHLY RECOMEND. A very good soap with all the necessary requirements. It shaves well, it smels good. it has great glide and it is in my cup. It will be in my cup in the future. The aftershave balm is also on my list. I like it, my girlfriend likes it and that is enough.

I haven't tried the Bay Rum, but may need to. I am really enjoying the New Spice soap and bath soap. Awesome fragrance!! Lynn

Yep Lynn, I agree. I just tried the new spice shave soap and shampoo. Awsome is the correct word to describe the scent.

Sue;--keep up the good work.