ah yes.. this has been a problem for me in the past as well.. a few girls ago i was forbidden to wear the pinaud clubman original.. yet the bay rum was allowed.. i traded up for a girl who liked both..
just try something else that you'll both like.. and i stress "BOTH LIKE".. do not wear something you don't care for simply because she does..
i find most girls in my dating age range like old spice.. give that a try and see what happens.